Skip to content

andsteing/vision_transformer

 
 

Repository files navigation

Vision Transformer and MLP-Mixer Architectures

Update (9.6.2022): Added the ResNet, ViT, and MLP-Mixer checkpoints optimized using "Surrogate Gap Minimization Improves Sharpness-Aware Training" (a.k.a. GSAM) paper (Table 1).

Update (14.4.2022): Added models and Colab for LiT models.

Update (2.7.2021): Added the "When Vision Transformers Outperform ResNets..." paper, and SAM (Sharpness-Aware Minimization) optimized ViT and MLP-Mixer checkpoints.

Update (20.6.2021): Added the "How to train your ViT? ..." paper, and a new Colab to explore the >50k pre-trained and fine-tuned checkpoints mentioned in the paper.

Update (18.6.2021): This repository was rewritten to use Flax Linen API and ml_collections.ConfigDict for configuration.

In this repository we release models from the papers

The models were pre-trained on the ImageNet and ImageNet-21k datasets. We provide the code for fine-tuning the released models in JAX/Flax.

Table of contents:

Colab

Below Colabs run both with GPUs, and TPUs (8 cores, data parallelism).

The first Colab demonstrates the JAX code of Vision Transformers and MLP Mixers. This Colab allows you to edit the files from the repository directly in the Colab UI and has annotated Colab cells that walk you through the code step by step, and lets you interact with the data.

https://colab.research.google.com/github/google-research/vision_transformer/blob/main/vit_jax.ipynb

The second Colab allows you to explore the >50k Vision Transformer and hybrid checkpoints that were used to generate the data of the third paper "How to train your ViT? ...". The Colab includes code to explore and select checkpoints, and to do inference both using the JAX code from this repo, and also using the popular timm PyTorch library that can directly load these checkpoints as well. Note that a handful of models are also available directly from TF-Hub: sayakpaul/collections/vision_transformer (external contribution by Sayak Paul).

The second Colab also lets you fine-tune the checkpoints on any tfds dataset and your own dataset with examples in individual JPEG files (optionally directly reading from Google Drive).

https://colab.research.google.com/github/google-research/vision_transformer/blob/main/vit_jax_augreg.ipynb

Note: As for now (6/20/21) Google Colab only supports a single GPU (Nvidia Tesla T4), and TPUs (currently TPUv2-8) are attached indirectly to the Colab VM and communicate over slow network, which leads to pretty bad training speed. You would usually want to set up a dedicated machine if you have a non-trivial amount of data to fine-tune on. For details see the Running on cloud section.

Installation

Make sure you have Python>=3.6 installed on your machine.

Install JAX and python dependencies by running:

# If using GPU:
pip install -r vit_jax/requirements.txt

# If using TPU:
pip install -r vit_jax/requirements-tpu.txt

For newer versions of JAX, follow the instructions provided in the corresponding repository linked here. Note that installation instructions for CPU, GPU and TPU differs slightly.

Install Flaxformer, follow the instructions provided in the corresponding repository linked here.

For more details refer to the section Running on cloud below.

Fine-tuning a model

You can run fine-tuning of the downloaded model on your dataset of interest. All models share the same command line interface.

For example for fine-tuning a ViT-B/16 (pre-trained on imagenet21k) on CIFAR10 (note how we specify b16,cifar10 as arguments to the config, and how we instruct the code to access the models directly from a GCS bucket instead of first downloading them into the local directory):

python -m vit_jax.main --workdir=/tmp/vit-$(date +%s) \
    --config=$(pwd)/vit_jax/configs/vit.py:b16,cifar10 \
    --config.pretrained_dir='gs://vit_models/imagenet21k'

In order to fine-tune a Mixer-B/16 (pre-trained on imagenet21k) on CIFAR10:

python -m vit_jax.main --workdir=/tmp/vit-$(date +%s) \
    --config=$(pwd)/vit_jax/configs/mixer_base16_cifar10.py \
    --config.pretrained_dir='gs://mixer_models/imagenet21k'

The "How to train your ViT? ..." paper added >50k checkpoints that you can fine-tune with the configs/augreg.py config. When you only specify the model name (the config.name value from configs/model.py), then the best i21k checkpoint by upstream validation accuracy ("recommended" checkpoint, see section 4.5 of the paper) is chosen. To make up your mind which model you want to use, have a look at Figure 3 in the paper. It's also possible to choose a different checkpoint (see Colab vit_jax_augreg.ipynb) and then specify the value from the filename or adapt_filename column, which correspond to the filenames without .npz from the gs://vit_models/augreg directory.

python -m vit_jax.main --workdir=/tmp/vit-$(date +%s) \
    --config=$(pwd)/vit_jax/configs/augreg.py:R_Ti_16 \
    --config.dataset=oxford_iiit_pet \
    --config.base_lr=0.01

Currently, the code will automatically download CIFAR-10 and CIFAR-100 datasets. Other public or custom datasets can be easily integrated, using tensorflow datasets library. Note that you will also need to update vit_jax/input_pipeline.py to specify some parameters about any added dataset.

Note that our code uses all available GPUs/TPUs for fine-tuning.

To see a detailed list of all available flags, run python3 -m vit_jax.train --help.

Notes on memory:

  • Different models require different amount of memory. Available memory also depends on the accelerator configuration (both type and count). If you encounter an out-of-memory error you can increase the value of --config.accum_steps=8 -- alternatively, you could also decrease the --config.batch=512 (and decrease --config.base_lr accordingly).
  • The host keeps a shuffle buffer in memory. If you encounter a host OOM (as opposed to an accelerator OOM), you can decrease the default --config.shuffle_buffer=50000.

Vision Transformer

by Alexey Dosovitskiy*†, Lucas Beyer*, Alexander Kolesnikov*, Dirk Weissenborn*, Xiaohua Zhai*, Thomas Unterthiner, Mostafa Dehghani, Matthias Minderer, Georg Heigold, Sylvain Gelly, Jakob Uszkoreit and Neil Houlsby*†.

(*) equal technical contribution, (†) equal advising.

Figure 1 from paper

Overview of the model: we split an image into fixed-size patches, linearly embed each of them, add position embeddings, and feed the resulting sequence of vectors to a standard Transformer encoder. In order to perform classification, we use the standard approach of adding an extra learnable "classification token" to the sequence.

Available ViT models

We provide models pre-trained on ImageNet-21k for the following architectures: ViT-B/16, ViT-B/32, ViT-L/16 and ViT-L/32. We provide the same models pre-trained on ImageNet-21k and fine-tuned on ImageNet.

Update (9.6.2022): We added the ViT models trained from scratch using GSAM on ImageNet without strong data augmentations. The resultant ViTs outperform those of similar sizes trained using AdamW optimizer or the original SAM algorithm, or with strong data augmentations. To use those models, you can simply replace the model path in vit_jax.ipynb with gs://vit_models/gsam.

Update (29.7.2021): Added ViT-B/8 AugReg models (3 upstream checkpoints and adaptations with resolution=224).

Update (2.7.2021): We added the ViT models trained from scratch with SAM optimizer on ImageNet (with basic Inception-style preprocessing). The resultant ViTs outperform ResNets of similar size and throughput without large-scale pre-training or strong data augmentations. They also possess more perceptive attention maps. To use those models, you can simply replace the model path in vit_jax.ipynb with gs://vit_models/sam.

Update (19.5.2021): With publication of the "How to train your ViT? ..." paper, we added more than 50k ViT and hybrid models pre-trained on ImageNet and ImageNet-21k with various degrees of data augmentation and model regularization, and fine-tuned on ImageNet, Pets37, Kitti-distance, CIFAR-100, and Resisc45. Check out vit_jax_augreg.ipynb to navigate this treasure trove of models! For example, you can use that Colab to fetch the filenames of recommended pre-trained and fine-tuned checkpoints from the i21k_300 column of Table 3 in the paper:

Model Pre-trained checkpoint Size Fine-tuned checkpoint Resolution Img/sec Imagenet accuracy
L/16 gs://vit_models/augreg/L_16-i21k-300ep-lr_0.001-aug_strong1-wd_0.1-do_0.0-sd_0.0.npz 1243 MiB gs://vit_models/augreg/L_16-i21k-300ep-lr_0.001-aug_strong1-wd_0.1-do_0.0-sd_0.0--imagenet2012-steps_20k-lr_0.01-res_384.npz 384 50 85.59%
B/16 gs://vit_models/augreg/B_16-i21k-300ep-lr_0.001-aug_medium1-wd_0.1-do_0.0-sd_0.0.npz 391 MiB gs://vit_models/augreg/B_16-i21k-300ep-lr_0.001-aug_medium1-wd_0.1-do_0.0-sd_0.0--imagenet2012-steps_20k-lr_0.03-res_384.npz 384 138 85.49%
S/16 gs://vit_models/augreg/S_16-i21k-300ep-lr_0.001-aug_light1-wd_0.03-do_0.0-sd_0.0.npz 115 MiB gs://vit_models/augreg/S_16-i21k-300ep-lr_0.001-aug_light1-wd_0.03-do_0.0-sd_0.0--imagenet2012-steps_20k-lr_0.03-res_384.npz 384 300 83.73%
R50+L/32 gs://vit_models/augreg/R50_L_32-i21k-300ep-lr_0.001-aug_medium1-wd_0.1-do_0.1-sd_0.1.npz 1337 MiB gs://vit_models/augreg/R50_L_32-i21k-300ep-lr_0.001-aug_medium1-wd_0.1-do_0.1-sd_0.1--imagenet2012-steps_20k-lr_0.01-res_384.npz 384 327 85.99%
R26+S/32 gs://vit_models/augreg/R26_S_32-i21k-300ep-lr_0.001-aug_light1-wd_0.1-do_0.0-sd_0.0.npz 170 MiB gs://vit_models/augreg/R26_S_32-i21k-300ep-lr_0.001-aug_light1-wd_0.1-do_0.0-sd_0.0--imagenet2012-steps_20k-lr_0.01-res_384.npz 384 560 83.85%
Ti/16 gs://vit_models/augreg/Ti_16-i21k-300ep-lr_0.001-aug_none-wd_0.03-do_0.0-sd_0.0.npz 37 MiB gs://vit_models/augreg/Ti_16-i21k-300ep-lr_0.001-aug_none-wd_0.03-do_0.0-sd_0.0--imagenet2012-steps_20k-lr_0.03-res_384.npz 384 610 78.22%
B/32 gs://vit_models/augreg/B_32-i21k-300ep-lr_0.001-aug_light1-wd_0.1-do_0.0-sd_0.0.npz 398 MiB gs://vit_models/augreg/B_32-i21k-300ep-lr_0.001-aug_light1-wd_0.1-do_0.0-sd_0.0--imagenet2012-steps_20k-lr_0.01-res_384.npz 384 955 83.59%
S/32 gs://vit_models/augreg/S_32-i21k-300ep-lr_0.001-aug_none-wd_0.1-do_0.0-sd_0.0.npz 118 MiB gs://vit_models/augreg/S_32-i21k-300ep-lr_0.001-aug_none-wd_0.1-do_0.0-sd_0.0--imagenet2012-steps_20k-lr_0.01-res_384.npz 384 2154 79.58%
R+Ti/16 gs://vit_models/augreg/R_Ti_16-i21k-300ep-lr_0.001-aug_none-wd_0.03-do_0.0-sd_0.0.npz 40 MiB gs://vit_models/augreg/R_Ti_16-i21k-300ep-lr_0.001-aug_none-wd_0.03-do_0.0-sd_0.0--imagenet2012-steps_20k-lr_0.03-res_384.npz 384 2426 75.40%

Update (1.12.2020): We have added the R50+ViT-B/16 hybrid model (ViT-B/16 on top of a Resnet-50 backbone). When pretrained on imagenet21k, this model achieves almost the performance of the L/16 model with less than half the computational finetuning cost. Note that "R50" is somewhat modified for the B/16 variant: The original ResNet-50 has [3,4,6,3] blocks, each reducing the resolution of the image by a factor of two. In combination with the ResNet stem this would result in a reduction of 32x so even with a patch size of (1,1) the ViT-B/16 variant cannot be realized anymore. For this reason we instead use [3,4,9] blocks for the R50+B/16 variant.

Update (9.11.2020): We have also added the ViT-L/16 model.

Update (29.10.2020): We have added ViT-B/16 and ViT-L/16 models pretrained on ImageNet-21k and then fine-tuned on ImageNet at 224x224 resolution (instead of default 384x384). These models have the suffix "-224" in their name. They are expected to achieve 81.2% and 82.7% top-1 accuracies respectively.

You can find all these models in the following storage bucket:

https://console.cloud.google.com/storage/browser/vit_models/

For example, if you would like to download the ViT-B/16 pre-trained on imagenet21k run the following command:

wget https://storage.googleapis.com/vit_models/imagenet21k/ViT-B_16.npz

Expected ViT results

Table below runs experiments both with transformer.dropout_rate=0.1 (as in the ViT paper), and with transformer.dropout_rate=0.0, which improves results somewhat for models B=16, B/32, and L/32. The better setting was chosen for the default config of the models in this repository. Note also that all these models have representation_size=None, i.e. the last layer before the classification layer is dropped for fine-tuning.

model dataset dropout=0.0 dropout=0.1
R50+ViT-B_16 cifar10 98.72%, 3.9h (A100), tb.dev 98.94%, 10.1h (V100), tb.dev
R50+ViT-B_16 cifar100 90.88%, 4.1h (A100), tb.dev 92.30%, 10.1h (V100), tb.dev
R50+ViT-B_16 imagenet2012 83.72%, 9.9h (A100), tb.dev 85.08%, 24.2h (V100), tb.dev
ViT-B_16 cifar10 99.02%, 2.2h (A100), tb.dev 98.76%, 7.8h (V100), tb.dev
ViT-B_16 cifar100 92.06%, 2.2h (A100), tb.dev 91.92%, 7.8h (V100), tb.dev
ViT-B_16 imagenet2012 84.53%, 6.5h (A100), tb.dev 84.12%, 19.3h (V100), tb.dev
ViT-B_32 cifar10 98.88%, 0.8h (A100), tb.dev 98.75%, 1.8h (V100), tb.dev
ViT-B_32 cifar100 92.31%, 0.8h (A100), tb.dev 92.05%, 1.8h (V100), tb.dev
ViT-B_32 imagenet2012 81.66%, 3.3h (A100), tb.dev 81.31%, 4.9h (V100), tb.dev
ViT-L_16 cifar10 99.13%, 6.9h (A100), tb.dev 99.14%, 24.7h (V100), tb.dev
ViT-L_16 cifar100 92.91%, 7.1h (A100), tb.dev 93.22%, 24.4h (V100), tb.dev
ViT-L_16 imagenet2012 84.47%, 16.8h (A100), tb.dev 85.05%, 59.7h (V100), tb.dev
ViT-L_32 cifar10 99.06%, 1.9h (A100), tb.dev 99.09%, 6.1h (V100), tb.dev
ViT-L_32 cifar100 93.29%, 1.9h (A100), tb.dev 93.34%, 6.2h (V100), tb.dev
ViT-L_32 imagenet2012 81.89%, 7.5h (A100), tb.dev 81.13%, 15.0h (V100), tb.dev

We also would like to emphasize that high-quality results can be achieved with shorter training schedules and encourage users of our code to play with hyper-parameters to trade-off accuracy and computational budget. Some examples for CIFAR-10/100 datasets are presented in the table below.

upstream model dataset total_steps / warmup_steps accuracy wall-clock time link
imagenet21k ViT-B_16 cifar10 500 / 50 98.59% 17m tensorboard.dev
imagenet21k ViT-B_16 cifar10 1000 / 100 98.86% 39m tensorboard.dev
imagenet21k ViT-B_16 cifar100 500 / 50 89.17% 17m tensorboard.dev
imagenet21k ViT-B_16 cifar100 1000 / 100 91.15% 39m tensorboard.dev

MLP-Mixer

by Ilya Tolstikhin*, Neil Houlsby*, Alexander Kolesnikov*, Lucas Beyer*, Xiaohua Zhai, Thomas Unterthiner, Jessica Yung, Andreas Steiner, Daniel Keysers, Jakob Uszkoreit, Mario Lucic, Alexey Dosovitskiy.

(*) equal contribution.

Figure 1 from paper

MLP-Mixer (Mixer for short) consists of per-patch linear embeddings, Mixer layers, and a classifier head. Mixer layers contain one token-mixing MLP and one channel-mixing MLP, each consisting of two fully-connected layers and a GELU nonlinearity. Other components include: skip-connections, dropout, and linear classifier head.

For installation follow the same steps as above.

Available Mixer models

Update (9.6.2022): We added the MLP-Mixer models (gs://mixer_models/gsam) trained from scratch with GSAM on ImageNet without strong augmentations. The resultant MLP-Mixers outperform those of similar sizes trained with AdamW optimizer or with the original SAM algorithm.

Update (2.7.2021): We added the MLP-Mixer models trained with SAM on ImageNet without strong augmentations (gs://mixer_models/sam). The loss landscapes become much smoother, and we found that the activated neurons for the first few layers decrease dramatically after SAM, indicating the potential redundency of image patches.

We provide the Mixer-B/16 and Mixer-L/16 models pre-trained on the ImageNet and ImageNet-21k datasets. Details can be found in Table 3 of the Mixer paper. All the models can be found at:

https://console.cloud.google.com/storage/mixer_models/

Note that these models are also available directly from TF-Hub: sayakpaul/collections/mlp-mixer (external contribution by Sayak Paul).

Expected Mixer results

We ran the fine-tuning code on Google Cloud machine with four V100 GPUs with the default adaption parameters from this repository. Here are the results:

upstream model dataset accuracy wall_clock_time link
ImageNet Mixer-B/16 cifar10 96.72% 3.0h tensorboard.dev
ImageNet Mixer-L/16 cifar10 96.59% 3.0h tensorboard.dev
ImageNet-21k Mixer-B/16 cifar10 96.82% 9.6h tensorboard.dev
ImageNet-21k Mixer-L/16 cifar10 98.34% 10.0h tensorboard.dev

LiT models

We have just published a post on the Google AI blog LiT: adding language understanding to image models about our new CVPR paper "LiT: Zero-Shot Transfer with Locked-image text Tuning" (https://arxiv.org/abs/2111.07991).

We provide a in-browser demo with small text encoders for interactive use (the smallest models should even run on a modern cell phone):

https://google-research.github.io/vision_transformer/lit/

And finally a Colab to use the JAX models with both image and text encoders:

https://colab.research.google.com/github/google-research/vision_transformer/blob/main/lit.ipynb

Note that none of above models support multi-lingual inputs yet, but we're working on publishing such models and will update this repository once they become available.

Running on cloud

While above colabs are pretty useful to get started, you would usually want to train on a larger machine with more powerful accelerators.

Create a VM

You can use the following commands to setup a VM with GPUs on Google Cloud:

# Set variables used by all commands below.
# Note that project must have accounting set up.
# For a list of zones with GPUs refer to
# https://cloud.google.com/compute/docs/gpus/gpu-regions-zones
PROJECT=my-awesome-gcp-project  # Project must have billing enabled.
VM_NAME=vit-jax-vm-gpu
ZONE=europe-west4-b

# Below settings have been tested with this repository. You can choose other
# combinations of images & machines (e.g.), refer to the corresponding gcloud commands:
# gcloud compute images list --project ml-images
# gcloud compute machine-types list
# etc.
gcloud compute instances create $VM_NAME \
    --project=$PROJECT --zone=$ZONE \
    --image=c1-deeplearning-tf-2-5-cu110-v20210527-debian-10 \
    --image-project=ml-images --machine-type=n1-standard-96 \
    --scopes=cloud-platform,storage-full --boot-disk-size=256GB \
    --boot-disk-type=pd-ssd --metadata=install-nvidia-driver=True \
    --maintenance-policy=TERMINATE \
    --accelerator=type=nvidia-tesla-v100,count=8

# Connect to VM (after some minutes needed to setup & start the machine).
gcloud compute ssh --project $PROJECT --zone $ZONE $VM_NAME

# Stop the VM after use (only storage is billed for a stopped VM).
gcloud compute instances stop --project $PROJECT --zone $ZONE $VM_NAME

# Delete VM after use (this will also remove all data stored on VM).
gcloud compute instances delete --project $PROJECT --zone $ZONE $VM_NAME

Alternatively, you can use the following similar commands to set up a Cloud VM with TPUs attached to them (below commands copied from the TPU tutorial):

PROJECT=my-awesome-gcp-project  # Project must have billing enabled.
VM_NAME=vit-jax-vm-tpu
ZONE=europe-west4-a

# Required to set up service identity initially.
gcloud beta services identity create --service tpu.googleapis.com

# Create a VM with TPUs directly attached to it.
gcloud alpha compute tpus tpu-vm create $VM_NAME \
    --project=$PROJECT --zone=$ZONE \
    --accelerator-type v3-8 \
    --version tpu-vm-base

# Connect to VM (after some minutes needed to setup & start the machine).
gcloud alpha compute tpus tpu-vm ssh --project $PROJECT --zone $ZONE $VM_NAME

# Stop the VM after use (only storage is billed for a stopped VM).
gcloud alpha compute tpus tpu-vm stop --project $PROJECT --zone $ZONE $VM_NAME

# Delete VM after use (this will also remove all data stored on VM).
gcloud alpha compute tpus tpu-vm delete --project $PROJECT --zone $ZONE $VM_NAME

Setup VM

And then fetch the repository and the install dependencies (including jaxlib with TPU support) as usual:

git clone --depth=1 --branch=master https://github.com/google-research/vision_transformer
cd vision_transformer

# optional: install virtualenv
pip3 install virtualenv
python3 -m virtualenv env
. env/bin/activate

If you're connected to a VM with GPUs attached, install JAX and other dependencies with the following command:

pip install -r vit_jax/requirements.txt

If you're connected to a VM with TPUs attached, install JAX and other dependencies with the following command:

pip install -r vit_jax/requirements-tpu.txt

Install Flaxformer, follow the instructions provided in the corresponding repository linked here.

For both GPUs and TPUs, Check that JAX can connect to attached accelerators with the command:

python -c 'import jax; print(jax.devices())'

And finally execute one of the commands mentioned in the section fine-tuning a model.

Bibtex

@article{dosovitskiy2020vit,
  title={An Image is Worth 16x16 Words: Transformers for Image Recognition at Scale},
  author={Dosovitskiy, Alexey and Beyer, Lucas and Kolesnikov, Alexander and Weissenborn, Dirk and Zhai, Xiaohua and Unterthiner, Thomas and  Dehghani, Mostafa and Minderer, Matthias and Heigold, Georg and Gelly, Sylvain and Uszkoreit, Jakob and Houlsby, Neil},
  journal={ICLR},
  year={2021}
}

@article{tolstikhin2021mixer,
  title={MLP-Mixer: An all-MLP Architecture for Vision},
  author={Tolstikhin, Ilya and Houlsby, Neil and Kolesnikov, Alexander and Beyer, Lucas and Zhai, Xiaohua and Unterthiner, Thomas and Yung, Jessica and Steiner, Andreas and Keysers, Daniel and Uszkoreit, Jakob and Lucic, Mario and Dosovitskiy, Alexey},
  journal={arXiv preprint arXiv:2105.01601},
  year={2021}
}

@article{steiner2021augreg,
  title={How to train your ViT? Data, Augmentation, and Regularization in Vision Transformers},
  author={Steiner, Andreas and Kolesnikov, Alexander and and Zhai, Xiaohua and Wightman, Ross and Uszkoreit, Jakob and Beyer, Lucas},
  journal={arXiv preprint arXiv:2106.10270},
  year={2021}
}

@article{chen2021outperform,
  title={When Vision Transformers Outperform ResNets without Pretraining or Strong Data Augmentations},
  author={Chen, Xiangning and Hsieh, Cho-Jui and Gong, Boqing},
  journal={arXiv preprint arXiv:2106.01548},
  year={2021},
}

@article{zhuang2022gsam,
  title={Surrogate Gap Minimization Improves Sharpness-Aware Training},
  author={Zhuang, Juntang and Gong, Boqing and Yuan, Liangzhe and Cui, Yin and Adam, Hartwig and Dvornek, Nicha and Tatikonda, Sekhar and Duncan, James and Liu, Ting},
  journal={ICLR},
  year={2022},
}

@article{zhai2022lit,
  title={LiT: Zero-Shot Transfer with Locked-image Text Tuning},
  author={Zhai, Xiaohua and Wang, Xiao and Mustafa, Basil and Steiner, Andreas and Keysers, Daniel and Kolesnikov, Alexander and Beyer, Lucas},
  journal={CVPR},
  year={2022}
}

Disclaimers

Open source release prepared by Andreas Steiner.

Note: This repository was forked and modified from google-research/big_transfer.

This is not an official Google product.

About

No description, website, or topics provided.

Resources

License

Stars

Watchers

Forks

Releases

No releases published

Packages

No packages published

Languages

  • Jupyter Notebook 94.3%
  • Python 5.7%