Comments back from MICCAI education challenge

[thompson318]

In GitLab by @StephenThompson on Oct 10, 2019, 13:47

REVIEWER 1

---

OVERALL SCORE
Weak Accept

PLEASE RATE THE ACCURACY OF CONTENT
4

PLEASE RATE THE COMPREHENSIVENESS OF CONTENT
5

PLEASE RATE THE APPROPRIATE LEVEL (ACCESSIBLE TO NEW MASTERS AND PHD STUDENTS?)
5

PLEASE RATE THE RELEVANCE TO THE MICCAI COMMUNITY
4

PLEASE RATE THE CLARITY
5

PLEASE RATE THE IMPACT FOR THE STUDENT COMMUNITY
4

PLEASE RATE THE IMPACT FOR THE RESEARCH COMMUNITY
4

HOW LIKELY WOULD YOU BE TO RECOMMEND THIS EDUCATIONAL MATERIAL TO A STUDENT WHO WAS INTERESTED IN THE TOPIC?
4

PLEASE LIST THE MAJOR STRENGTHS OF THE TUTORIAL (BULLETED LIST)
The topic is relevant and description is clear. Videos are helpful.

PLEASE LIST ANY MAJOR WEAKNESSES OF THE TUTORIAL (BULLETED LIST)
Real medical application would be helpful.

SUGGESTIONS TO THE AUTHORS / OTHER FEEDBACK
as stated, if some medical applications could be added, it would be very useful.

REVIEWER 2

---

OVERALL SCORE
Strong Accept

PLEASE RATE THE ACCURACY OF CONTENT
5

PLEASE RATE THE COMPREHENSIVENESS OF CONTENT
4

PLEASE RATE THE APPROPRIATE LEVEL (ACCESSIBLE TO NEW MASTERS AND PHD STUDENTS?)
5

PLEASE RATE THE RELEVANCE TO THE MICCAI COMMUNITY
5

PLEASE RATE THE CLARITY
5

PLEASE RATE THE IMPACT FOR THE STUDENT COMMUNITY
4

PLEASE RATE THE IMPACT FOR THE RESEARCH COMMUNITY
4

HOW LIKELY WOULD YOU BE TO RECOMMEND THIS EDUCATIONAL MATERIAL TO A STUDENT WHO WAS INTERESTED IN THE TOPIC?
4

PLEASE LIST THE MAJOR STRENGTHS OF THE TUTORIAL (BULLETED LIST)

• Comprehensive first steps in AR.
• No need to compile anything.
• Easy installation for Python proficient users.
• All source code and printable materials provided.

PLEASE LIST ANY MAJOR WEAKNESSES OF THE TUTORIAL (BULLETED LIST)

• The vtk actor is connected to the ArUco tag in a problematic manner. Initially, when the tag was detected the actor disappeared. It was only visible when the tag was moved far enough from the camera (about 2m away) and the offset between the tag location and the projection of the vtk actor was unexpectedly large. Possibly issue is also due to problem with unknown/incorrect marker size.

SUGGESTIONS TO THE AUTHORS / OTHER FEEDBACK

• The installation instructions should start with downloading the files from the repo and then installing via the requirements.txt file found in the repo.

• The vtk actor is connected to the ArUco tag in a problematic manner. Initially, when the tag was detected the actor disappeared. It was only visible when the tag was moved far enough from the camera (about 2m away) and the offset between the tag location and the projection of the vtk actor was unexpectedly large. Possibly issue is also due to problem with unknown/incorrect marker size.

• I would strongly suggest providing a camera calibration program, instead of a fixed camera matrix.

• The rigid tracking of the markers also depends on the known marker size (otherwise transformation known up to scale). It is unclear what is the expected marker size in mm. When printing it, the settings should probably not use "fit to page". This will be an issue when default paper sizes are possible A4/letter.

[thompson318]

In GitLab by @StephenThompson on Dec 18, 2019, 12:17

assigned to @StephenThompson