You signed in with another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You signed out in another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You switched accounts on another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.Dismiss alert
GTFS FLex V1 not fully supported because stop_id is required in stop_time
Steps to reproduce:
How can we reproduce the issue? modify a stop_times file to have a null stop_id in an entry and a valid start_service_area
Expected behavior:
Per the GTFS Flex Spec a, technically, correct interpretation is that the stop_id in stop_times.txt can be null if there is a start or end service area provided. Although most agencies have followed the suggestion to include a phantom stop in the middle of the service area proper adherence to the spec does not require it.
To support that I propose making the stop_id optional. Then after reading in the GTFS validate that all provided stop_times have a stop_id unless the entry includes a start or end service_area.
Observed behavior:
GTFS Modules throws an error because the stop_id is required
The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered:
Summary:
GTFS FLex V1 not fully supported because stop_id is required in stop_time
Steps to reproduce:
How can we reproduce the issue? modify a stop_times file to have a null stop_id in an entry and a valid start_service_area
Expected behavior:
Per the GTFS Flex Spec a, technically, correct interpretation is that the stop_id in stop_times.txt can be null if there is a start or end service area provided. Although most agencies have followed the suggestion to include a phantom stop in the middle of the service area proper adherence to the spec does not require it.
To support that I propose making the stop_id optional. Then after reading in the GTFS validate that all provided stop_times have a stop_id unless the entry includes a start or end service_area.
Observed behavior:
GTFS Modules throws an error because the stop_id is required
The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered: