CMI 5 Subgroup Meeting Notes – Oct 20th, 2023

cmi5 Subgroup Meeting Notes – Oct 20th, 2023

Attendee List

• Andy Johnson
• Bill McDonald
• Brian Miller
• Christopher Thompson
• Florian Tolk
• George Vilches
• Henry Ring
• Jim Taite
• Megan Bohland
• Simon Hsu
• Yifei Dong

Notes

---

The group discussed the following items:

• Add Issues in the New IEEE cmi5 repository (once operational) for all "Derived Requirements" defined in the CATAPULT documentation.
• The the cmi5 specification will need all of the "MUST"s changed to "SHALL"s to meet IEEE requirements
• Re-organize document structure to explicitly itemize requirements (without grouping/flow) in order eliminate duplicating/overlapping requirements language. (see the example: https://xhr.spec.whatwg.org/#the-open()-method )

The group reviewed the following "Derived Requirements" (from CATAPULT documentation):

• 3.0.0.0-1 (d): The LMS must reject course structure data that contains non-fully qualified IRIs or IRI references in any data element using an IRI value space.
  • Moveto course structure requirements section – instead of definitions
• 4.2.0.0-1 (d): The endpoint provided by the LMS passes the ADL LRS conformance test suite.
  • Add reference to xAPI Spec
  • All xAPI communication must comply with the xAPI specification
  • Conformance Test Suite shouldn’t be references
• 4.4.0.0-1 (d): The LMS must reject courses that do not conform to requirements listed in Section 13 or Section 14.
  • This is a collection of requirements and should be removed as each individual requirement will be specified in the spec
• 4.4.0.0-2 (d): The LMS must reject course structure data that does not conform to the specification.
  • This is a collection of requirements and should be removed as each individual requirement will be specified in the spec
• 6.0.0.0-1 (d): The endpoint provided by the LMS passes the ADL LRS conformance test suite.
  • The endpoint provided by the LMS must be xAPI conformant
• 7.1.1.0-1 (d1): The LMS must track that the AU has issued an "Initialized" statement.
  • The LMS has to reject statements issued by the AU before the AU issues an initialized statement.
• 7.1.1.0-1 (d2): The LMS must reject attempts by the AU to store statements or void stored statements received before the "Initialized" statement.
  • The LMS has to reject statements issued by the AU before the AU issues an initialized statement.
  • The LMS has to reject VOIDed statements issued by the AU before the AU issues an initialized statement.
  • Void is covered in 7.1.3.0-1 (d1)

---

All Previous cmi5 Meeting Minutes/Notes

https://github.com/AICC/CMI-5_Spec_Current/wiki

cmi5 on GitHub:

http://aicc.github.io/CMI-5_Spec_Current/